Monday, 8 February 2010

Alone in Berlin by Hans Fallada

I've started this review and deleted it too many times because I don't quite know what to say about Alone in Berlin. It managed to be both easy to read and incredibly difficult at the same time. The writing itself was easy, however the subject matter made for some rather uncomfortable reading at times. Based in Germany under the Nazi regime, and during the war, it took a completely different angle from any other novel I've read about this period. It was mainly about the German people and how individuals responded to the strict rules of the regime, and although Nazi atrocities played an important part of the story, they were never the main focus.


Otto and Anna Quangel live a quiet life in Berlin, saving their money, keeping their heads down and living a fairly uneventful life. They do the bare minimum to keep the authorities happy, joining and contributing to the relevant organisations, but nothing above what is required of them. Also in their building live the Persickes, a fiercely Nazi family who see it their duty to fulfil Hitler's mission, a old Jewish lady (things don't go well for her), Borkhausen, who is a workshy gadabout and Judge Fromm, who is another person who keeps his head down, but does try to help people, in very small ways.

It is the small things in this novel that are the most important. When the Quangels receive the dreaded letter informing them their son has fallen in battle, an angry comment from Anna sets in motion a series of events that end in disaster in an entirely predictable, but still shocking way. Almost immediately after the news is received, Anna says to Otto

"And now he's supposed to be an exemplary soldier, and dies a hero's death? Lies, all a pack of lies! but that's what you get from your wretched war, you and that Fuhrer of yours!"

After mulling this over, seemingly for weeks, Otto decides upon a plan to deliver postcards with anti-Nazi slogans printed on them, in which he involves his wife, although not against her will. For the first half of the book, this is what the story focuses on, as well as various interlinked stories involving the other members of the building and how they decide to either support or (surreptitiously) defy the ruling party, and at various occasions, the characters stories intersect.

We also get a detailed look at the attitude of the Gestapo officers and the methods and measures they use to trap their victims. And trap is a good word, because in one specific case, not related to the Quangels, the person meets a very sticky end and has absolutely nothing to do with what he is being accused of.

I could go on for pages about the plot of this book because there is so much involved, and it is quite a long book. But I think the most important thing about this is the insight into the attitude of the German people towards the situation they find themselves in. This book does give the impression that resistance to the Nazi's was futile, but not only because they would always get you in the end, as well as most of your family, and possibly anyone who might be associated with you. Otto Quangel's expectations of what his postcards will achieve are grossly over-estimated in his head, and we see his pride at what he thinks he is achieving juxtaposed with the relatively easy way in which the Gestapo manage to trace him, through the cards that the general public are too scared to read. The fear of retribution from the general population, the apathy in which they accept the restrictions placed on them, and the individual pride and dignity of those that do try to do something, even when it becomes clear it is futile are what make this novel so moving and thought provoking.

I just wanted to finish with a couple of quotes that I thought summed up the points this book was trying to make about Nazi Germany, although in reality, I could have quoted the whole book for this.

"While the Hergesells were being tormented for a crime they hadn't committed, party member Persicke was forgiven for one he had."


"But there were many days ahead of them, and this particular SS man was never on duty in their corridor again. He had probably been dismissed as too unsuitable-he was too human to do duty here."

6 comments:

Sandra said...

I have The Drinker in my library and Every Man Dies Alone on it's way from the library so I'll finally be getting around to reading Fallada. This book sounds interesting to me as we get the German people's perspective on the war. Again, you know how to choose your quotes. That last one is a little chilling.

The Reader said...

This reminds me of a German friend who I went to University with. She always insisted that her family during WWII was terrified of the party in power and were just trying to get by without rocking the boat too much. This, I believe does give an insight into how Germans who lived in Germany thought-- probably not completely conscious of the crimes committed in their name... perhaps there are similar parallels in many countries today??

The Reader
I'm a Bookworm

Jo said...

Sandra, I could have picked any number of quotes that were just as chilling. It was full of them!

I also think the two titles are interesting. Having read it, they seem to focus on different aspects of the novel. Every man Dies alone I believe is closer to the original German though.

The reader, I'm fairly sure it is happening all over the world today. I think however much we would all want to stand up for what is right, human nature is for life preservation.
In a way its a damning indictment of humanity and society.

coffeestainedpages said...

It sounds like a very powerful book. I have that problem often where it's really difficult to work out what to say in a book review. With some books it's so difficult to express how you felt about them.

Jo said...

This was definitely one of those books. It was brilliant, but there was so much I wanted to say, it was difficult to know where to start. And what to leave out!

santhi priya said...

A truly motivational and life changing book
me: A truly motivational and life changing book
This book is really a good book which shows us right path. but i read
one more book named "ONE BOOK FOR LIFE SUCCESS" which is truly
motivational and life changing . .The writer has described in Plain
English with lot of examples which is easy to understand...For More
Please watch the videohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=biORjS8ng